REACTORTürkçe

35 facts

Economics

35 facts about economics from 4 Rialo sources. Each one is the explanation Reactor shows after a question, followed by the exact line it rests on.

Test yourself on this topic in Atlas

Upgrading the Consumer Lending Stack

Rialo integrates data access, private computation and automation as protocol features because complements to execution belong in the base layer.

“consistent with Rialo's supermodular design philosophy, which holds that features complementing execution should be integrated into the base layer rather than delegated to middleware.”

Rialo Foundations I: Double Marginalization in Crypto

The post says developers blame gas, scaling or friction, but the deeper issue is middleware costs stacking up across the stack.

“But there's another, deeper issue at play: the compounding cost of middleware.”

Because many monopolistic layers each add a markup, the post prefers compound marginalization over the textbook two layer term.

“While double marginalization is the original term, compound marginalization is a more accurate description of what happens in crypto.”

Compound marginalization selects for price insensitive users like whales and traders, so useful everyday apps never get built.

“It's no surprise, then, that we see a "crypto desert": a landscape dominated by speculative financial tools and a dearth of useful, non-financial applications.”

The post says compounding costs can wipe out up to 90% of surplus, leaving only high margin, price insensitive uses like leveraged DeFi.

“These costs can erase up to 90% of total economic surplus, leaving only high-margin, price-insensitive use cases–like leveraged DeFi–to survive.”

Collapsing several fee setting layers into one system lets pricing be set with total throughput and user welfare in mind.

“Rialo's vertical integration has an important side effect: pricing coordination.”

The post argues blockchains should take on more of the functions developers already rely on instead of staying minimal.

“This calls for questioning one of crypto's most persistent dogmas (i.e., that base-layer blockchains should do as little as possible)”

Scheduling, data and indexing costs stack on top of the base fee, so $1 of gas can carry more than $5 of extra service costs.

“In the case of a lending protocol, an application that spends $1 on gas could incur over $5 in extra costs before the loan is successfully liquidated.”

The post uses this figure to show how middleware takes a cut: about 5% of each loan goes to liquidation bots.

“Additionally, lenders like Aave pay roughly 5% of each loan to liquidation bots.”

The post says Aave's average loan is around $100,000, based on $9 billion borrowed across 90,000 monthly borrowers.

“Given that Aave's average loan size is around $100,000 (based on $9 billion in total borrows across 90,000 monthly borrowers), that translates to an extra $5,000 per liquidation in operational overhead.”

Each layer extracts rent from the same pool of users while assuming the others will moderate their fees, which the post calls a tragedy of the commons for pricing.

“Rialo is also designed to mitigate what we call a "tragedy of the commons for pricing." In the current ecosystem, each layer of infrastructure extracts rent from the same pool of users, assuming the others will moderate their fees.”

The breakdown is 300% extra for scheduling, 200% extra for data and $4,000 per month for indexing fast results.

“300% extra for scheduling 200% extra for data $4,000 per month for indexing fast results”

The post defines deadweight loss as pure waste from coordination failure that no user, developer or blockchain gains from.

“Formally, deadweight loss is the value destroyed when uncoordinated pricing prevents mutually beneficial trade.”

This line is from the post Rialo Foundations I: Double Marginalization in Crypto.

“Solving crypto’s compound marginalization problem requires both first-principles thinking and a look at what has worked elsewhere.”

This line is from the post Rialo Foundations I: Double Marginalization in Crypto.

“Astute readers might notice that this feels like an example of double marginalization in practice.”

Rialo Foundations II: Supermodularity and Blockchain Integration

Rialo treats integration as an economic decision and calls the resulting philosophy supermodularity.

“At Rialo, we treat integration as an economic decision and adopt a systematic, quantitative framework that decides which components are integrated into the protocol and which remain external. We call this philosophy supermodularity.”

Smartphones combined GPS, payments and phones, which unlocked ride hailing, logistics and e-commerce that none could enable alone.

“Initially, GPS, payment systems, and phones existed independently until smartphones came and combined all three functions into a single system.”

Hyperliquid started as a trading app and migrated to a chain that fused pricing, execution and liquidation into one engine.

“Hyperliquid is a great example: they started as a trading app and then migrated to a chain that integrated price feeds and risk-management primitives with execution.”

Components that reinforce each other in production are integrated; everything else is bought as a commodity from external providers.

“This yields a simple heuristic for designing supermodular systems: integrate the supermodulars and commoditize the complements.”

A better fiat onramp makes the chain easier to use but does not make execution more capable, so Rialo treats it as a commodity.

“Fiat onramping is an example of a component that complements blockchain execution in consumption but not in production.”

Rialo integrates attestation and verifiable computation but sources the raw data, like weather from Weather.com, externally.

“The data itself (e.g., weather information) is often a commodity, and the costs of integrating data provision outweigh the benefits. But attesting to the provenance of data and performing confidential and verifiable computation using attested data are supermodular functions.”

The post says the bridge between Rialo and other chains is operated by the chain's own validator set.

“Interoperability is native to Rialo: users can transfer assets and send messages between Rialo and other chains via a bridge operated by the chain's validator set.”

This line is from the post Rialo Foundations II: Supermodularity and Blockchain Integration.

“Take, for example, a lending platform that calculates a user’s creditworthiness and loanable amount based on real-world credit scores.”

This line is from the post Rialo Foundations II: Supermodularity and Blockchain Integration.

“Rialo supports hybrid execution that combines onchain and offchain components through a combination of native web calls, confidential computation, and data attestation.”

Supermodularity and System Welfare: The Economics of Integration

High welfare means valuable onchain activity is cheap, reliable and scalable; fragmentation and rent extraction lower it.

“We define system welfare as the total value created for developers and users after accounting for execution costs, coordination overhead, and operational risk.”

The post says concentrating control trades some decentralization for coordination and alignment in pricing and delivering services.

“Concentrating control of critical functions into one entity (the chain itself) trades off some decentralization for greater coordination and alignment in the pricing and delivery of execution and execution-adjacent services.”

Higher fees discourage usage while delayed liquidations let bad debt pile up, so users rationally exit either way.

“When this happens, protocols can either raise fees for users or throttle liquidation frequency.”

Stitching together bridges, oracles and privacy gadgets raises operational risk because those pieces can go offline, censor or get exploited.

“Middleware providers do not provide the same guarantees of availability, censorship resistance, and decentralization as the base layer.”

The post says the services do not automatically become free; the chain has pricing power but can offer them at a lower price.

“Those extra services don't automatically become free, but the chain has monopoly pricing power and can offer them at a lower price.”

Surveys cited in the post put monthly offchain infrastructure spend in the hundreds of thousands, worst on high throughput chains.

“Currently, developer surveys show that protocol teams are spending hundreds of thousands of dollars per month to integrate their applications with offchain infrastructure”

Lower prices grow demand, and at scale the manufacturer cuts unit costs, so overall profit rises despite the cheaper product.

“Reducing prices (counterintuitively) leads to higher margins because cheap products stimulate demand–as demand scales, the manufacturer can reduce unit production costs and make more profits overall.”

Integration only pays when components are strategically complementary; everything else is outsourced and treated as a commodity input.

“It is important to clarify that this doesn't mean a blockchain should integrate everything.”

The post frames supermodularity as vertical integration applied to blockchains: bring complementary services into the protocol.

“Vertical integration of complementary production components is the core insight of supermodularity.”

This line is from the post Supermodularity and System Welfare: The Economics of Integration.

“Existing blockchains often fail to integrate supermodular components and fragment the stack into multiple layers.”

This line is from the post Supermodularity and System Welfare: The Economics of Integration.

“Solving compound marginalization requires coordinating price-setting, which is hard to do when each provider has an incentive to maximize its own profit.”

Other topics